Dr. Balvinder Mehat Cleared in Circumcision Case After Tribunal Accepts He Was Misled by Boy’s Mother Over Parental Consent Dispute

A medical tribunal ruled that Dr. Balvinder Mehat was misled by the boy's mother, who allegedly claimed she was the only parent with parental responsibility
A man sitting with a laptop and a court gavel in front.
Mehat’s barrister, Ghazan Mahmood, argued that the mother had misled his client, leaving Mehat unaware that the boy’s father shared parental responsibility.Sora Shimazaki /Pexels
Published on: 
Updated on: 

The UK medical tribunal has cleared Dr. Balvinder Mehat of misconduct in the case of circumcising a patient.

The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) hearing took place between November 2 and November 16, 2026. The tribunal concluded that Dr. Mehat's fitness to practise was not impaired, allowing him to continue practising without restrictions arising from this case.

​MedBound Times previously reported about  Dr. Mehat who had circumcised a seven-year-old boy on October 19, 2022, at the Bakersfield Medical Centre in Nottingham, without the child’s father's consent.

Dr. Balvinder Mehat was referred to a Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) hearing by the General Medical Council (GMC) after being accused of misconduct.

​According to a recent BBC report, the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service said that Dr. Mehat was misled by the child’s mother. The boy’s mother had allegedly provided the doctor with a birth certificate that did not mention the father’s name, and she told the doctor that she was the child’s only parent with parental responsibility.

​The Tribunal stated that Dr. Mehat had already made the necessary inquiries before he performed the procedure; hence, he could continue practising medicine in the UK.

Dr. Balvinder Mehat Cleared in Circumcision Case: What Did the Medical Tribunal Decide?

According to the reports, the child’s mother was not a single parent and was indeed married to the father of the child at the time of the circumcision procedure. She had simply not added the father’s name to the birth certificate and had not mentioned the father in the consent form at the hospital.

​Consequently, Mehat’s barrister, Ghazan Mahmood, argued that the mother had misled his client, leaving Mehat unaware that the boy’s father shared parental responsibility.

The MPTS panel, in its statement, said, "The tribunal considered that Dr. Mehat's evidence was credible and reliable, supported by contemporaneous documentation.

"The tribunal was satisfied that he had made enquiries about who had parental responsibility for Patient A and was told directly that Ms C [the mother] was the only one.”

​In an interview with the BBC, Dr. Mehat said that he is very grateful for the way MPTS handled the case and that the team had reviewed the evidence in a fair manner.

​He said, “The allegations against me were originally made in 2022. I am relieved that this case is now over and my name has been cleared. As a GP for many years, I am and have always been dedicated to patient care."

The GMC hearing also heard allegations about the consent forms. Dr. Mehat was accused of asking the boy's mother to sign a disclaimer on October 24, 2022, after the circumcision had already taken place. He was also alleged to have asked her to sign another disclaimer on December 8, backdated to October 19, the date of the procedure.

A stethoscope on a blue mat.
Dr. Mehat faced the tribunal again in December 2024. He was given a warning after he made comments about muslim patients.Steppe Walker/Pexels

Parental Consent Dispute Emerges in Dr. Balvinder Mehat Circumcision Case

The boy was circumcised on October 19, 2022, at the Bakersfield Medical Centre.

​The parents were married in 2019; however, they were separated at the time of the circumcision. The mother stated that she wanted the child circumcised for spiritual and cultural reasons.

​Guidance from the British Medical Association and GMC suggests that consent should be obtained from both parents.

The GMC's guidance on personal beliefs and medical practice states that when a child does not have sufficient maturity and understanding to provide consent, doctors should obtain consent from all those with parental responsibility. It also advises doctors to seek court authorisation if a disagreement between parents cannot be resolved informally.

​During the investigation of the case, the tribunal also reviewed the consent form that was signed by the child’s mother. The form clearly stated, "All those with parental responsibility are aware of the procedure above to be carried out without any disagreement or disputes."

​Ms C told the tribunal she had understood the content of the consent form but signed it anyway.

​On October 17, 2022, Dr. Mehat spoke to the mother and was told that there were no other people with parental responsibility.

​According to the reports, the father discovered the circumcision issue a few days later. On 22 October, he contacted Dr. Mehat to complain. On 23 October, he contacted Dr. Mehat again to inform him that he had taken Patient A to A&E at Royal Derby Hospital in the middle of the night. He stated that Patient A was in ‘agony’. It was discovered that the Plastibell had become displaced and there was an infection in the area.

Dr. Balvinder Mehat's Previous Medical Tribunal Cases: Suspensions and Warnings

One of the allegations that Dr. Mehat faced was that he didn’t include the seven-year-old boy in the decision-making procedure for the boy’s circumcision.

However, Dr. Mehat’s lawyer said this allegation could not be made, as the GMC had not supported the case with any evidence.

​The tribunal agreed, and this allegation was therefore removed.

​According to the reports, Dr. Mehat had faced four tribunals in total. In March 2019, he was suspended for a month when his fitness to practise was determined to be impaired because the Nottingham City Council stated that he was involved in a few offences regarding rental property that was owned by him.

In September 2019, he was suspended for a month because he circumcised a baby without the parents’  consent.

Dr. Mehat faced the tribunal again in December 2024. He was given a warning after he made comments about muslim patients.

(Rh/ARC/MSM)

A man sitting with a laptop and a court gavel in front.
Nottingham GP Faces Medical Tribunal for Circumcising Seven Year Old Boy Without Seeking His Opinion or Father’s Consent