New York Doctor Sentenced in Japan After Vandalizing Historic Temple and Shrine With Oil

Tokyo, Japan: A New York-based gynecological surgeon specializing in endometriosis treatment has been sentenced to 18 months in prison, suspended for three years, after a Japanese court found him guilty of damaging two ancient religious sites by splashing oil on sacred wooden structures more than a decade ago.

The Chiba District Court on Thursday convicted Masahide Kanayama, 63, a Japanese national and legal permanent resident of the United States, for vandalizing Naritasan Shinshoji Temple in Narita and Katori Jingu Shrine in Katori on March 25, 2015. The sentencing follows a years-long international legal battle that ended with his extradition from the United States earlier this year.

Kanayama admitted during the trial that he poured the oil but said he believed he had been acting under spiritual guidance. The court ruled that his religious beliefs did not justify damaging culturally significant heritage sites.

Also see: US Judge Dismisses Sexual Abuse Lawsuit Against Former Indiana University Team Doctor Over Time Limit

Delivering the verdict, Judge Yoko Sugiyama emphasized the historical and cultural importance of the two religious sites, stating that Kanayama's actions deserved "strong condemnation" because he prioritized his personal religious beliefs over the law.

The court sentenced Kanayama to 18 months' imprisonment, but suspended the sentence for three years, taking into account his remorse, willingness to compensate for the damage, and promise not to repeat the offense.

During the hearing, Kanayama apologized and told the court he would never splash oil on religious sites again.

According to prosecutors, Kanayama splashed an oil-like liquid onto wooden pillars at Naritasan Shinshoji Temple, a Buddhist temple with a history spanning more than 1,000 years.

He also poured oil on structures at Katori Jingu Shrine, one of Japan's oldest Shinto shrines, traditionally believed to have been founded in 643 B.C.

Temple officials said the oil left dark stains on wooden pillars, while shrine authorities reported traces of oil on wooden posts, stairways, and an offertory box. Although some marks later became less visible, officials said the damage affected culturally significant structures and was difficult to repair.

Also see: Indian-Origin Doctor Alleges ICE Stopped Her US Citizen Mother Over Accent in Texas

Japanese authorities first sought Kanayama's extradition in 2016, shortly after he left Japan following the incidents.

The doctor extradited from the United States to Japan challenged the request through the U.S. court system for several years. A federal district court approved the extradition, and subsequent appeals were unsuccessful, clearing the way for his transfer to Japan earlier this year.

He was arrested after arriving in Japan on a commercial flight in March.

Investigators said surveillance footage, rental car records, and flight information helped identify Kanayama as a suspect in the Japanese temple vandalism case. Authorities also referred to publicly available YouTube videos in which he discussed anointing shrines with oil for religious purposes.

Throughout the proceedings, Kanayama maintained that he never intended to desecrate the religious sites.

His defense argued that he applied only a small amount of plant-based oil as part of what he believed was a religious act of blessing and purification rather than an attempt to damage the buildings.

The defense also argued during the U.S. extradition proceedings that Kanayama had been unfairly targeted because he was a Christian. Japanese authorities rejected that claim, stating that the extradition request and criminal prosecution were based solely on law enforcement considerations.

During the trial, however, Kanayama acknowledged that his actions had been misguided.

"I poured the oil believing I was being guided by the Holy Spirit, but it was my own misconception," he told the court, according to Japan's public broadcaster NHK.

Kanayama practiced medicine in Manhattan for nearly three decades and specialized in the surgical treatment of endometriosis, a chronic gynecological condition in which tissue similar to the uterine lining grows outside the uterus. The condition affects millions of women worldwide and can cause severe pelvic pain, infertility, and a reduced quality of life.

In addition to his medical practice, Kanayama founded the International Marketplace Ministry, a Christian nonprofit organization that promotes integrating faith into everyday life and professional work.

Before his extradition, Kanayama said he viewed medicine as an extension of his religious beliefs and considered surgery a way of serving both patients and God.

Japanese investigators have previously linked the 2015 incidents to a broader series of religious site vandalism cases reported at 48 shrines and temples across 16 prefectures.

The affected locations included nationally important cultural properties and UNESCO World Heritage sites such as Nijo Castle, Toji Temple, and Todaiji Temple.

Authorities used security camera footage and travel records during their investigation as they examined multiple incidents involving oil being applied to historic religious structures across the country.

The Masahide Kanayama case attracted international attention because it combined issues of religious belief, cultural heritage protection, and international extradition. It also highlighted the legal cooperation between Japan and the United States in cross-border criminal cases involving damage to nationally significant heritage sites.

The sentencing marks the latest development in a legal case that has spanned more than a decade.

(Rh/ARC/MSM)