A senior consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) is calling for a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian. @andrewlearmonth/X
Medicine

Senior Surgeon Calls for NHS Grampian Corporate Homicide Investigation After 19 Preventable Deaths

Whistleblower Dr. Mohammed Habib alleges an “industrial-scale cover-up” of preventable liver and pancreatic surgery deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary

Author : Akanksha

A senior consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) is calling for a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian, following findings from an unpublished external investigation, which revealed that at least 19 patients died from avoidable surgical complications. 

Dr. Mohammed Habib, who has worked in general and hepatopancreatobiliary (HPB) surgery at the hospital since 2014, went public alongside his solicitor Aamer Anwar on Thursday. Speaking at a press conference, Dr. Habib said he was putting his career on the line to expose what he described as an “industrial-scale cover-up” of avoidable deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery. 

Whistleblower Dr. Mohammed Habib Claims Preventable Liver and Pancreatic Surgery Deaths at ARI

Dr. Habib raised concerns about preventable surgical outcomes in 2016 and formally submitted whistleblowing complaints in July 2021. He believes the toll runs to “several dozen” of avoidable deaths, with hundreds more patients suffering avoidable harm. 

Reading a statement on Dr. Habib's behalf, Aamer Anwar delivered a stark assessment of the unit. As reported by BBC News, Anwar said: “Catastrophically, the operating theatre he worked in at times could be described as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence whilst not giving a damn for accountability.”

Dr. Habib also said that two patients died after undergoing incorrect surgical procedures. Their families were never informed of the errors. Calling on the Lord Advocate, Ruth Charteris KC, to instruct Police Scotland to launch a criminal probe, Dr. Habib stated that NHS Grampian showed “wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths,” as reported by STV News. 

Also Read: The Difference Between Medical Malpractice and General Medical Errors

Findings of NHS Grampian External Investigations in 2022 and 2026

Following formal complaints from Dr. Habib and a second whistleblower, NHS Grampian’s medical director, commissioned an external investigation by two experts in the field. Professor Stephen Wigmore from the University of Edinburgh and Professor Giles Toogood from the University of Leeds investigated 45 cases from 2015 to 2021. 

Aberdeen Royal Infirmary Mortality Rates Up to 9 Times Higher Than the National Average

The findings from the 2022 investigation, which were not published, showed that 31 out of 45 patients had died. Of these, 19 were found to have died as a result of “avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention”. 

Between 2017 and 2020, the 30-day mortality rate for major liver resections at ARI was 12% and 18% at 90 days. This compared to an expected national average of 2.2-3%. The mortality rate for Whipple's operation on the pancreas at ARI was significantly higher than the Scottish oversight network limit of 1 in 20. Roughly 1 in 7 patients undergoing Whipple's operation at ARI died within one month. 

The investigation highlighted “repeated issues” with poor leadership, poor decision-making, poor pre-operative planning and optimisation, and poor surgical technique. Surgeons were sometimes “too aggressive,” performing surgery on inoperable disease, and causing “unacceptably high” blood loss. 

Suspension of Complex HPB Surgery at NHS Grampian in 2026

Despite these findings, complex surgery resumed in full in May 2023. However, with another death occurring in late 2024, Whipple’s operations were transferred to Edinburgh. In January 2025, Professor Wigmore stated that continuing Whipple's operations at ARI was “no longer tenable.”

In November 2025, Dr. Habib highlighted further preventable deaths, at least four, to Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS). One patient died on the operating table during a minor liver operation on November 26. All complex liver and pancreatic surgery was suspended at NHS Grampian in January 2026. In March 2026, external advisor Raaj Praseedom recommended permanent closure of major HPB surgery at ARI, stating that "persistent high mortality in complex surgery is a red-flag indicator of systemic failure.”

Ignored Whistleblower Warnings to Scottish Ministers, Watchdogs, and Police Scotland

Between 2023 and 2026, Dr. Habib repeatedly raised concerns to ministers in the Scottish Government, including former First Minister Humza Yousaf, current First Minister John Swinney, and Health Secretaries Michael Matheson and Neil Gray. Correspondence from Dr. Habib shows that senior government officials were made aware of the findings of the 2022 report in October 2022. However, ministers told Dr. Habib that it was outside their remit to investigate individual whistleblowing cases in health boards. 

In November 2025, the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer (INWO) also declined to investigate Dr. Habib’s concerns, citing that they were “out of time” or “outside their remit.”

Dr. Habib first raised 20 cases with Police Scotland in early 2024. Following the press conference on Thursday, Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar told BBC News that Police Scotland had received a report in 2024 “following several deaths.” She added that “Inquiries are being carried out. A situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.” The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) confirmed that investigations are underway. 

Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra called for criminal investigations to be undertaken into “systemic failures” at the health board, stating that the 19 families “deserve answers and deserve justice.”

Political Reaction and Responses from NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government

The allegations come just days after a separate Healthcare Improvement Scotland review found “very serious shortcomings” in NHS Grampian. The review found that paediatric surgery continued at Dr. Gray’s Hospital in Elgin, despite being asked to stop. 

Calls for an NHS Grampian Criminal Investigation in Holyrood

Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra called for criminal investigations to be undertaken into “systemic failures” at the health board, stating that the 19 families “deserve answers and deserve justice.” However, First Minister John Swinney stated that while the allegations are “of the gravest concern,” he is not supporting calls for a government-led criminal investigations as they have recently had new leadership in place and urgent changes. Previously, Health Secretary Angela Constance warned MSPs that NHS Grampian may be placed into special measures if the changes do not work. 

Also Read: A Victim of Medical Malpractice Deals with These 5 Challenges in Their Life

Responses from NHS Grampian Chief Executive and BMA Scotland

Laura Skaife-Knight, Chief Executive of NHS Grampian, whose resignation Dr. Habib and Anwar are demanding, said in a statement: “A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing. Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered. NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.” She added that if required, processes of duty of candour are undertaken, and patient safety remains the top priority of the board, as reported by The Guardian. 

A Scottish Government spokesperson told The Guardian that ministers “recognise the courage shown by the whistleblower,” and added that if a criminal investigation is to be undertaken, it is a matter for Police Scotland. Meanwhile, BMA Scotland Chair Dr. Nóra Murray-Cavanagh told STV News that the “incredibly serious and distressing allegations” must be a catalyst for creating a “learn not blame culture” in healthcare. That frontline voices can be heard. 

(Rh/APC)

He Sees His Cat’s Eyes on People and Human Features on His Cat: The Rare Visual Disorder That Emerged After Brain Surgery

NMC Orders KGMU Lucknow Ragging Inquiry After Viral ‘Pranam Mahoday Ji’ Video

Before You Start GTA VI, Here's How to Make Long Gaming Sessions Healthier

Hong Kong Surgeon Accidentally Removes 45-Year-Old Woman’s Ovaries During Surgery; Hospital Cites a Cognitive Lapse

DGHS Approves Equal Stipends for Foreign Medical Graduates at 5 Government Institutions: What the 2026 Order Means for FMG Interns