In September 2026, a surgeon who was working at the Chinese University of Hong Kong Medical Centre allegedly removed both ovaries of a 45-year-old woman during a surgery for removal of her uterus and fallopian tubes.
On November 17, 2026, the CUHK medical centre apologised and attributed the surgical mistake to a cognitive lapse by the surgeon. The incident was also reported to the Department of Health on September 13 this year.
The surgery took place on September 12, 2026. Following the incident, CUHK Medical Centre established a Root Cause Analysis Panel to investigate the circumstances surrounding the error. The hospital also reported the incident to the Department of Health within 24 hours, as required under the Private Healthcare Facilities Ordinance.
According to a South China Morning Post report, Professor Cheung Tak-Hong admitted he was the surgeon responsible for the mistake.
Cheung said the operation was difficult and that he became so focused on one aspect of the procedure that he lost sight of the original surgical plan.
He said, "The operation was a bit difficult, and I was too focused on one thing, and my mind missed the original plan. I don't want to explain further … because a mistake is a mistake. I should admit my mistakes and bear the responsibility.”
The incident came to light when a nurse noticed both ovaries among other surgical specimens during her routine verification. Moments later, the surgeon was notified that removal of the ovaries was not part of the surgery.
The hospital's CEO later clarified that the error did not involve the surgeon misidentifying the ovaries or other reproductive organs. Instead, the surgeon failed to remain aware of the patient's chosen treatment plan and proceeded with the alternative surgical approach. The hospital also clarified that its earlier description of the incident as a "cognitive blind spot" was an imperfect translation of the term "temporary collapse of situational awareness". The CEO described it more simply as a lapse in concentration.
However, the surgeon removed the patient's ovaries. According to the hospital CEO, the surgeon encountered difficulties while using the laparoscope to access the surgical area, a process that took about 15 to 20 minutes. The surgeon subsequently lost focus and proceeded with the wrong surgical approach. The mistake was brought to the patient's family on the same day. The surgeon also took responsibility for the mistake when contacted by the CEO of the hospital at around 10 pm.
Cheung, a veteran obstetrician and gynaecologist specialising in gynecological oncology, led the obstetrics and gynaecology department at Prince of Wales Hospital before his retirement. He also serves as an honorary clinical professor at CUHK's medical school.
The CUHK medical centre didn’t name the surgeon during its press conference on November 18.
CEO Chung described Cheung as a reputable surgeon but said that he lost his focus during the surgery.
Chung also clarified that the surgeon was employed by the medical centre on a contract basis as an obstetrician and gynaecologist.
Following the incident, the hospital offered the patient the option of continuing her treatment with the same surgeon or switching to another doctor. However, she chose to continue her follow-up care with Cheung. The patient was reportedly shocked and disappointed after learning about the mistake. The hospital and the surgeon agreed to cover the costs of her follow-up consultations and treatment.
The accidental removal of both ovaries can also affect the body's hormone levels and cause early menopause.
A spokesperson said that the patient was in stable condition after the surgery.
The spokesperson told the South China Morning Post, “There was no evidence showing that the hospital had breached the code of practice requirements on premises, staffing or equipment in a way that led to the sentinel event.”
According to the CUHK Medical Centre, the situation is highly concerning. The hospital said that the incident is reported as a sentinel event. The hospital authorities defined it as “an unexpected occurrence involving death or serious physical or psychological injury, or the risk thereof”.
The CUHK medical centre said that the hospital has already apologised to the woman and her family and will readily provide any medical support or follow-ups whenever needed.
They added, “The hospital has conducted a comprehensive review of the incident, and will implement appropriate follow-up and improvement measures based on the findings.”
Cheung told SCMP that the hospital will determine his disciplinary action. He stated that he will accept their decision, whether they restrict his practice or allow him to continue working under additional safeguards.
(Rh/ARC/MSM)