Justice Guru said that new rules or policy relaxations only apply once they are issued and cannot be applied to past events unless explicitly stated. Amiyashrivastava (talk) (Uploads)/Wikimedia Commons
India

Chhattisgarh HC Rejects 15 Government Doctors’ Plea for 36-Month Study Leave, Says 2025 Rule Cannot Apply Retrospectively

The Chhattisgarh High Court ruled that a later relaxation allowing longer study leave cannot be applied to leave granted under the earlier rules

Author : Arushi Roy Chowdhury

Chhattisgarh: On October 1, 2026, the Chhattisgarh High Court ruled that a new rule that allows longer study leave cannot be applied to the candidates who were granted study leave before the new rule came into force.

​On Thursday, Justice Bibhu Datta Guru disposed of petitions filed by certain doctors seeking to extend their 24 months' study leave to 36 months. They were asking for an extension of one year; however, the court dismissed it their petitions.

​According to the reports, the court stated that the particular state order that relaxed the period of study leave from 24 months to 36 months applied to those seeking study leave after the rule was implemented.

​Hence, only candidates who seek permission for study leave on or after the date of issuance of the new rule are eligible for the extended study leave period.

Chhattisgarh HC Rejects Government Doctors’ Plea for 36-Month Study Leave

Most of the petitioners are working as dental surgeons and medical officers under the Department of Health and Family Welfare. These doctors were granted study leave to prepare for their postgraduate medical courses under the old Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 2010.

According to the prevailing rules, the doctors were eligible for 24 months of study leave, which was followed by a year of extraordinary leave to complete their three-year courses.

Chhattisgarh Study Leave Rules: How the 36-Month Extension Was Introduced for Government Doctors

On March 3, 2025, an order was issued by the state government under which Rule 44 of the Leave Rules, 2010 was relaxed and changed. The new version of the rule allowed doctors to take study leave for a period of 36 months depending on special bond rules.

The court distinguished between doctors who had already been granted and availed 24 months of study leave under the earlier rules and those whose three-year study leave had already been sanctioned. It held that the March 3, 2025, relaxation could not retrospectively extend the leave already availed by the petitioners.

​The petitioners approached the court to seek permission to extend their 24 months' study leave to 36 months' study leave under the new rules.

​The doctors argued that the policy could be beneficial to many of them and also alleged that the department granted a similar extension to one of the fellow doctors on June 13, 2025.

However, the extension granted to the other doctor was cancelled on July 31, 2026, after the Finance Department raised an objection. The court held that the cancelled order could not establish an enforceable right to the same benefit for the petitioners.

​The lawsuit also targeted an April 6, 2026, departmental advisory. That notice confined the newly extended 36-month educational leave specifically to medical staff who had obtained authorization and NOCs after the March 2025 order.

The court also explained that the April 6, 2026 notice did not change the March 3, 2025 order; it just explained it.

What the Court Said About 24-Month and 36-Month Study Leave ​for Government Doctors

Additional Advocate General YS Thakur argued that the government’s relaxation of the study leave rules could not reopen transactions that had already been concluded.

​The court also stated that the extension granted to one doctor on June 13, 2025, was later cancelled on July 31, 2026, because the Finance Department objected to it

​The High Court agreed with the state government and dismissed all the petitions. Justice Guru said that new rules or policy relaxations only apply once they are issued and cannot be applied to past events unless explicitly stated.

The doctors also argued that denying them the benefit granted to another doctor violated Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, which concern equality before the law and equality of opportunity in public employment, respectively. The court rejected their claims, finding no violation of their equality rights.

​(Rh/ARC/MSM)

Supreme Court Seeks Centre’s Response on Consanguineous Marriages and Genetic Risks to Children

Blood-Based Neurology Biomarkers Are Accelerating Early Alzheimer’s Research Workflows

Meet Sivaranjani Santosh: Hyderabad Doctor Who Made a ₹9-Crore Rare Disease Drug Available Free of Cost to 7 Children

Synthetic Patient Personas: A New Tool for Healthcare Innovators, or a Shortcut to Avoid?

Clinicians Warn That Untreated Adolescent Anxiety Often Fuels Teen Substance Use