He was admitted to intensive care for acute alcoholic pancreatitis, alcoholic liver disease, bilateral pleural effusion, ascites, and abnormal kidney and pancreatic values. Stéf -b/pexels
India

Specialist Away, BAMS Doctors in the ICU: NCDRC Clears Gastroenterologist, Orders Amritsar Hospital to Pay Rs. 5 Lakh

Overturning a Rs. 40 lakh Punjab State Commission award, the NCDRC rules that leaving a critically ill pancreatitis patient without qualified allopathic cover amounts to hospital service deficiency

Author : Akanksha

Amritsar: A hospital in Amritsar has been ordered to pay compensation of Rs. 5 lakh, along with litigation expenses of Rs. 50,000, to the widow of a 33-year-old man who died while undergoing treatment for acute alcoholic pancreatitis. Although the gastroenterologist in charge of the patient was found not to have committed medical negligence, the hospital will be liable for service deficiency as it placed BAMS doctors in charge of a critically ill patient while the primary specialist was away at a conference. The order, dated November 13, overturns an earlier decision of the Punjab State Consumer Commission, which had awarded the patient’s widow Rs. 40 lakh. 

Case Background: Acute Alcoholic Pancreatitis Admission

On August 2, 2017, a 33-year-old man, who had a history of heavy alcohol consumption and convulsions, was referred to the Liver and Digestive Disease Centre in Amritsar. He was admitted to intensive care for acute alcoholic pancreatitis, alcoholic liver disease, bilateral pleural effusion, ascites, and abnormal kidney and pancreatic values. The patient underwent a CT scan on August 3, 2017, which showed a Grade E pancreatitis, with a severity score of 6 to 7. 

Initial Treatment and Discharge From the ICU 

The hospital claimed that standard treatment was provided. Over the first two days, laboratory values improved. However, on August 4, 2017, the patient was transferred from the Intensive Care Unit to a general ward, as requested by the patient’s father. The father signed a handwritten note to take full responsibility for any adverse outcomes. 

Gastroenterologist Away and Supervision by BAMS Doctors 

On August 5 and 6, 2017, the gastroenterologist was away from the hospital attending a medical conference. During this time, a nephrologist attended to the patient, monitored his vitals, and kept in regular contact with the gastroenterologist. However, within the center, the patient was under the supervision of two BAMS doctors and nursing staff. On the evening of August 6, 2017, the patient’s condition worsened rapidly. He experienced severe abdominal pain, abdominal distension, confusion, and respiratory difficulty. He was returned to the ICU after the doctor arrived. The patient’s condition continued to deteriorate on August 7. He developed high-grade fever, hypotension, and multiple organ involvement from sepsis and septic shock. As he required advanced ventilation for ARDS, he was referred and transferred to Fortis Escorts Hospital on August 8. Unfortunately, the patient died on August 9. 

Also Read: Meet Sivaranjani Santosh: Hyderabad Doctor Who Made a ₹9-Crore Rare Disease Drug Available Free of Cost to 7 Children

Medical Board Findings and the Punjab State Commission’s Rs. 40 Lakh Award

Following the patient’s death, a complaint was made to the police. This led to an investigation by a Medical Board, set up by the Civil Surgeon in Amritsar. It was concluded that standard treatment had been provided, meaning that there was no direct medical negligence. However, it was noted that no MBBS doctors were in attendance for 24 hours. 

Separately, the patient’s wife applied to the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Punjab. She submitted that her husband had been left in charge of non-allopathic doctors (BAMS) without continuous specialist supervision, in breach of the Medical Council of India Ethics Regulations, 2002. She also claimed that there had been tampering with medical records. On October 27, 2020, the State Commission decided in favor of the complainant and found that the hospital and gastroenterologist were liable. The patient’s wife was awarded Rs. 40 lakh and litigation of Rs. 33,000, with interest of 7%. Both parties appealed to the NCDRC. 

Why the Gastroenterologist Was Found Free of Medical Negligence

The central issue in this case was whether the hospital committed service deficiency by leaving a critically ill patient in the ICU to be supervised by BAMS doctors during a specialist’s absence, even if it could not be concluded that the specialist committed medical negligence.

She submitted that her husband had been left in charge of non-allopathic doctors (BAMS) without continuous specialist supervision, in breach of the Medical Council of India Ethics Regulations, 2002.

Applying well-established principles of medical negligence, including, Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee, Jacob Mathew v State of Punjab, Kusum Sharma v Batra Hospital, S.K. Jhunjhunwala v Dhanwanti Kaur, and M.A. Biviji v Sunita, it was decided that the gastroenterologist was free of medical negligence. The patient was critically ill with severe acute pancreatic disease and multi-organ involvement upon admission. The complainant did not provide any opposing expert medical evidence. Additionally, on August 5 and 6, 2017, the patient was seen by a nephrologist. Finally, it was legal for the specialist to attend medical conferences recognized by the MCI. 

Also Read: 10-Year-Old Boy Dies in Delhi's Narela After Firecracker Explodes; Family Alleges Hospital Negligence and Delayed Medical Treatment

Hospital Found Guilty of Service Deficiency for BAMS Supervision in ICU

Despite finding the doctor free of medical negligence, the hospital was found guilty of service deficiency. The NCDRC applied NABH guidelines and Regulations 7.10 of the MCI guidelines to conclude that, on August 5 and 6, 2017, the hospital in Amritsar failed to provide expected supervision and monitoring of the critically ill patient by a qualified allopathic doctor. 

As highlighted by The Indian Express, the NCDRC stated on November 13:

“The hospital remains responsible not only for the acts of the treating doctors but also for services rendered by nursing staff/para-medical staff and other services expected to be delivered from time to time during the course of treatment.”

With regard to Ayurvedic doctors within an allopathic ICU, the bench stated: 

“BAMS doctors are at times employed in some hospitals for patient care coordination, though they are not expected to be allocated independent allopathic clinical duties to manage ICUs/emergencies.”

Final Award and Payment Time Frame

Therefore, the Rs. 40 lakh award given by the State Commission was overturned. The hospital has been ordered to pay a total of Rs. 5 lakh, alongside litigation costs of Rs. 50,000. This must be paid within 4 weeks; otherwise, interest of 9% per annum will apply.  
(Rh/APC)

Japanese Woman Falls Sick in Japan, Viral Video Reveals Why She Misses Indian Healthcare

GMC Srinagar Resident Doctors Launch Indefinite Strike Over Stipend Hike, Pay Parity and Maternity Benefits Across Jammu and Kashmir

Supreme Court Seeks Centre’s Response on Consanguineous Marriages and Genetic Risks to Children

Blood-Based Neurology Biomarkers Are Accelerating Early Alzheimer’s Research Workflows

Meet Sivaranjani Santosh: Hyderabad Doctor Who Made a ₹9-Crore Rare Disease Drug Available Free of Cost to 7 Children