India has made progress in establishing a digital health record system. Polina Zimmerman/Pexels
Medicine

Over a Decade of Rules, Yet Still Carrying Paper Files: Why India’s Digital Health Vision Hasn’t Reached Every Clinic

India set national Electronic Health Record standards more than a decade ago. Yet, patients continue to carry medical records between hospitals. What is holding back the shift to connected healthcare?

Author : Mariyam F.

When entering most clinics and hospitals in India, you will often see patients carrying heavy plastic folders containing medical records such as old prescriptions, test results, and X-rays.

India began implementing its National Electronic Health Record (EHR) Standards in 2013. These were updated in 2016 by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW). A National Resource Centre for EHR Standards (NRCeS) was also established at C-DAC, Pune, to encourage implementation among healthcare providers.

Internationally recognised SNOMED CT has also been made freely available for use in India.

So, why do patients still carry paper copies?

India has made progress in establishing a digital health record system, with more than 119.95 crore health records linked to over 97.61 crore ABHA accounts under the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM). However, several challenges remain.

EMR vs. EHR: Where the Confusion Starts

Electronic Medical Record (EMR)

These are electronic versions of medical records maintained by a particular hospital or clinic. They contain information from consultations, prescriptions, and test results and are primarily used within that healthcare facility.

Electronic Health Record (EHR)

An EHR provides a more comprehensive view of a patient's health history and is designed to be shared across different healthcare providers.

For healthcare providers to exchange information between hospitals, their systems need to communicate with one another. This is known as interoperability.

Four Reasons the Shift Has Stalled on the Ground 

Writing a policy document is one thing; getting it to work inside a crowded, fast-moving Indian clinic is another. Four practical bottlenecks explain why adoption remains patchy:

1. Hospital Computers That Don’t Speak the Same Language

Many hospitals have adopted digital systems to manage information such as billing, appointments, prescriptions, and medical records. However, these systems may be specific to individual hospitals and may not communicate easily with one another.

Standards such as Health Level Seven (HL7) and Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR) help address this challenge. They provide common frameworks for exchanging information through standardised data structures and APIs.

However, systems must also use compatible data formats and clinical terminologies. Even when a healthcare provider uses FHIR, information may still need to be downloaded, printed, or manually entered if the systems are not properly integrated.

2. The Cost Reality for Small Clinics 

Initially, there was no universal obligation for healthcare providers to adopt the EHR standards. A government response in 2015 clarified that the standards were not mandatory at the time.

Large hospital chains may have the resources to invest in new systems. However, smaller nursing homes and independent practitioners often face financial constraints.

To encourage adoption, the National Health Authority introduced the Digital Health Incentive Scheme (DHIS) in 2023 under ABDM. It provides incentives to eligible healthcare providers and digital solution providers for creating and linking digital health records.

The revised scheme includes a minimum requirement of 100 eligible transactions per month for health facilities. While this can encourage adoption, smaller providers may still need more affordable digital solutions.

3. Crowded OPDs vs. Clunky Screens 

Even when hospitals invest in digital systems, getting healthcare staff to use them consistently can be challenging.

Doctors often have limited time, and complicated software with multiple screens and lengthy dropdown menus can make entering diagnoses and other clinical information difficult.

Standards such as SNOMED CT for clinical terminology and LOINC for laboratory tests help ensure that information is understood consistently across systems. However, these standards must be supported by software that is easy for clinicians to use.

If documentation becomes too complicated, doctors may prefer free-text entries or scanned documents. This can make the information harder for other systems to interpret.

4. Hesitation Over Data Privacy

Medical records contain sensitive personal information, making patients understandably concerned about data breaches, unauthorised access and misuse.

ABDM has introduced a mechanism through which individuals can consent to sharing their health records with participating healthcare providers.

India has also introduced the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, followed by the DPDP Rules, 2025. However, the provisions are being implemented in phases.

Legal safeguards and consent mechanisms are important, but healthcare providers must also have appropriate systems to protect patient data and ensure that only authorised individuals can access it. Patients need to feel confident that their medical information is being handled responsibly.

India has established a strong foundation through its policies and digital health initiatives.

How the U.S. Made Connected Care Routine 

MedBound Times Connected with Dr. Munish Kumar Raizada, US-based MD Neonatologist who mentioned the US offers an interesting example of large-scale EHR adoption. He said that many hospitals and clinics use established EHR platforms such as Epic, Oracle Health (formerly Cerner), and MEDITECH. 

According to the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, more than 99% of non-federal acute care hospitals had adopted certified EHRs by 2024.

The US government encouraged adoption through the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act of 2009, which provided financial incentives for healthcare providers adopting certified EHR systems.

The 21st Century Cures Act of 2016 further strengthened patients' ability to access their health information and addressed barriers to information sharing.

Although challenges with interoperability remain, the US experience offers useful lessons for India. India does not need to replicate the American model, but it can learn from the policies that encouraged adoption.

What America Got Right; and How India Can Catch Up 

Three areas deserve attention:

  1. Link digital records with funding: Incentives through government healthcare schemes and insurance programmes could encourage digital adoption, while maintaining appropriate safeguards for patient consent and privacy.

  2. Make systems affordable and easy to use: Smaller clinics need accessible, mobile-friendly platforms with features such as voice-to-text documentation and easy access to previous records.

  3. Put patients first: ABDM can make digital records more useful by supporting easy-to-use applications in regional languages, allowing patients and families to access and share their medical information.

India has established a strong foundation through its policies and digital health initiatives. However, real progress will depend on whether doctors can access relevant medical information from other healthcare providers when treating a patient.

This requires affordable technology, user-friendly systems, and robust data protection. Most importantly, smaller clinics and independent practitioners must also be able to participate in the digital health ecosystem.

India has spent more than a decade building this foundation. Now, the focus must shift towards making digital health accessible and practical enough that patients no longer need to carry their medical histories in plastic folders from one hospital to another.

References:

  1. "EHR Privacy in India: Navigating Challenges and Implementing Solutions." International Journal of Current Science (IJCSPUB) 15, no. 1 (2025).

  2. National Resource Centre for EHR Standards (NRCeS). "About NRCeS: Electronic Health Record (EHR) Standards for India (2013 and 2016)." Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. https://www.nrces.in/.

  3. National Resource Centre for EHR Standards (NRCeS). "Home: Role of the National Resource Centre for EHR Standards." Centre for Development of Advanced Computing (C-DAC), Pune. https://www.nrces.in/.

  4. National Resource Centre for EHR Standards (NRCeS). "EHR Standards for India: SNOMED CT Free-Use Policy, Affiliate Licensing, and National Release Centre Guidelines." Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. https://www.nrces.in/.

  5. Osamika, D., B. S. Adelusi, et al. "A Critical Review of Health Data Interoperability Standards: FHIR, HL7, and Beyond." World Scientific News 203 (2025): 194–233.

  6. Press Information Bureau (PIB) and National Health Authority (NHA). "NHA Extends Digital Health Incentive Scheme under ABDM." Government of India. https://abdm.gov.in/.

  7. Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC). National Trends in Hospital and Physician Adoption of Electronic Health Records and USCDI Interoperability Standards. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. https://www.healthit.gov/.

AIIMS Delhi Performs India's First Open Fetal Repair for Myelomeningocele in an Unborn Baby at 25 Weeks

Mumbai Resident Doctors Threaten ‘Bheekh Maango Andolan’ Over Delayed Stipends

20-Day-Old Baby Dies During Loud DJ Procession in UP's Ballia; Police Seize Equipment as Post-Mortem Remains Inconclusive

Father Admitted a Relationship, but Can He Be Ordered to Take a DNA Test? Karnataka High Court Sets Aside Family Court Order in Maintenance Case

Spill Your Feels: Dr. Prerna Kohli on Workplace Stress, Fear of Physical Intimacy and the Emotional Toll of a 10-Year Situationship